Current:Home > NewsGermany’s highest court overturns a reform that allowed for new trials after acquittals-InfoLens
Germany’s highest court overturns a reform that allowed for new trials after acquittals
View Date:2024-12-23 14:26:37
BERLIN (AP) — Germany’s highest court on Tuesday overturned a reform to the country’s criminal code that allowed for people who have been acquitted to be put on trial again for the same crime if new evidence emerged that could secure their conviction for murder or other serious crimes.
The Federal Constitutional Court declared the change, which took effect in December 2021, null and void after considering a challenge by a man who was acquitted of raping and killing a 17-year-old girl in the 1980s and faced new proceedings after an examination of DNA traces.
It found that the provision violated both a constitutional clause that precludes anyone being “punished for the same crime more than once” and a ban on applying the law retroactively.
The 2021 provision stated that proceedings already closed with a final judgement can be reopened “if new facts or evidence are produced which, independently or in connection with evidence which was previously taken, establish cogent reasons that the acquitted defendant will be convicted” of murder, genocide, crimes against humanity or a war crime against a person.
The trigger for Tuesday’s ruling was a complaint by a man who was accused of raping and fatally stabbing a schoolgirl in 1981. He was initially convicted of murder and rape and sentenced to life in prison, but appealed and was acquitted at a retrial for lack of evidence.
He was arrested on the basis of the new legal provision last year following a 2012 examination of DNA evidence, but released after the constitutional court issued an injunction. The court ruled Tuesday that the new case against him must be stopped.
The presiding judge, Doris Koenig, said the court was aware that its ruling would be “painful and certainly not easy to accept” for the family of the murdered girl.
But she said the right not to be tried again for the same crime by a German court after proceedings are concluded is “absolute” under the constitution. That, she added, leaves legislators “no room for maneuver even if it turns out in retrospect that the verdict was incorrect.”
veryGood! (58)
Related
- Sister Wives’ Kody Brown Explains His Stance on His Daughter Gwendlyn Brown’s Sexuality
- 4 stabbed in series of unprovoked attacks; suspect shot dead by officer: Police
- Toast the End of Harry Styles' Tour With Facts That Taste Like Strawberries on a Summer Evenin'
- Shakira Is Facing Another Tax Fraud Investigation in Spain
- Pitchfork Music Festival to find new home after ending 19-year run in Chicago
- Gilgo Beach murders: Police searching suspect's walk-in vault
- Former Columbia University OB-GYN to be sentenced for sexual abuse conviction
- Everything to Know About Carlee Russell's Faked Disappearance
- What Just Happened to the Idea of Progress?
- The View Co-Creator Bill Geddie Dead at 68
Ranking
- Whoopi Goldberg calling herself 'a working person' garners criticism from 'The View' fans
- Salma Hayek’s Secret to Maintaining Her Appearance Will Surprise You
- Love Island U.K.'s Molly-Mae Hague and Tommy Fury Engaged After Welcoming Baby
- Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds' Matilda Date Night Is Sweet as Honey
- Joey Logano wins Phoenix finale for 3rd NASCAR Cup championship in 1-2 finish for Team Penske
- Israel approves divisive judicial overhaul, weakening court's power amid protests
- NASA's mission to purposely collide with asteroid sent 'swarm of boulders' into space
- Get Cozy With 60% Off Barefoot Dreams Deals: Cardigans, Blankets, Pajamas, Loungewear, and More
Recommendation
-
Congress is revisiting UFOs: Here's what's happened since last hearing on extraterrestrials
-
Kim Kardashian and Tristan Thompson Party in Miami After Watching Lionel Messi's MLS Debut
-
We Solemnly Swear You'll Want to See Daniel Radcliffe's Transformation Over the Years
-
Disney Singer CoCo Lee’s Funeral Details Shared
-
Olivia Munn Says She “Barely Knew” John Mulaney When She Got Pregnant With Their Son
-
Lindsay Lohan’s Brother Dakota Gushes Over Her “Perfect” Baby Boy
-
Pete Davidson Gets Community Service Time for Reckless Driving Charge
-
Israel approves divisive judicial overhaul, weakening court's power amid protests